Updated 06/03/2014
Here is an early Easter Egg for you, crack it open and you will find a golden and glowing review of John Connolly’s The Book of Lost Things…
It is hard to beat Angela Carter’s potent re-imaginings of traditional Fairy Tales but John Connolly may boast a valiant and successful attempt.
Young hero, David’s struggle to adjust to his step-family under the shadow of The Blitz is realistic and heartfelt but unfortunately the tone alters and the pace flounders during a flabby middle section inspired by tired and predictable medieval quest romances.
Connolly’s work suffers a little under too many influences; Narnia, Oz, Wonderland, Labyrinth and even The Box of Delights are all thrown into the mix. Focus is restored most triumphantly however in a dramatic ending which is surprisingly horrific considering the overall Young Adult tone.
The Book of Lost Things, with its exquisite title, could have possessed more depth if freed from the influence of so many other contemporary retellings of old tales. Despite this, when Connolly finds his own voice the story soars and delivers a truly terrifying villain.
Interesting…
LikeLike
It’s sometimes a little frustrating to read a book so close to brilliant but with some niggling little problems. I did love it though, and it’s a quick read so worth a look x
LikeLike
Nice review – clear and to the point. Thanks
LikeLike
I would really like to read this solely based on the cover and your review. It sounds really wonderful.
LikeLike
Hi Cassie, it is a lovely book, the little problems are frustrating because it is so close to perfect, I hope you do seek it out and enjoy it! x
LikeLike
I’ll have to let you know what I think when I do. I’ll add it to my never-ending pile : )
LikeLike
I’ve read that book! Loved it, but as you said, it wasn’t perfect.
Must read Angela Carter’s faerytales someday- at the moment I’m almost finished her novel, Nights at the Circus.
LikeLike
OOOooooooo, I want to read that one too. She really is the Grandmama of scary Faery xx
LikeLike
“Scary Faery”? Hmm, might just have to borrow that expression…
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Lily Wight.
LikeLike
yes, what a wonderful title
LikeLike
I agree! It’s well worth a read 🙂 xxx
LikeLike